Abu Dawood 4131 Fixed Online

However, the controversy usually stems from a variation or a similar narration within the same chapter that seemingly implies the Earth is flat. In some manuscripts and printings, the text was translated or interpreted to suggest that the sun sets in a muddy spring ( tain ) or that the Earth is spread out in a way that negates spherical shape.

Muawiyah informs Al-Miqdam of the death of Al-Hasan ibn Ali. Al-Miqdam responds with "Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un," signifying a great loss. The Confrontation: abu dawood 4131 fixed

. In this narration, Al-Miqdam confronts Mu'awiyah regarding specific prohibitions established by the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ). Hadith Text (Sunan Abi Dawud 4131) English Translation: However, the controversy usually stems from a variation

It contrasts Miqdam's generosity (distributing the gift) with another member of the delegation (the Asadi) who kept his portion, highlighting different character traits recognized by Muawiya. Al-Miqdam responds with "Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi

Muawiyah, acknowledging the truth of the rebuke, famously replied: .

There are varying scholarly opinions on the authenticity of this specific narration: